Join the Neopoet online poetry workshop and community to improve as a writer, meet fellow poets, and showcase your work. Sign up, submit your poetry, and get started.

Winter Oaks

The undressed oaks of winter
Stretch their fingers to the sky,
Contemplating autumn's end,
And sharing silent wintry cries.

Brown leaves have faded to the ground
And back again to dust,
Breaking underneath my feet,
Veiled beneath the frosty crust.

They stand helpless in the bitter cold,
Some bent from ancient storms,
Keeping watch in winter's twilight,
These majestic, dormant forms.

Like these oaks, I now abide
In a haunting, cold embrace.
I, also, long for spring to come
And show its warm, bright face.

Catherine M. Howell
1/3/08

Last few words: 
This poem and another of my poems were published in our local "Brazos Gumbo" journal, volume 8. I was so excited as I never thought anything I wrote could ever get published. A small journal, but oh so wonderful an experience.
Editing stage: 

Comments

and nature, two of my favorite things! Nice work. ~ Geezer

There is value to commenting and critique, tell us how you feel about our work.
This must be the place, 'cause there ain't no place like this place anywhere near this place.

Thank you very kindly, Geezer:))) I love everything "nature."

Kind Regards,

wolfycat

I forgot my old signature so this one will have to do for a while!

author comment

On the whole I cannot appreciate rhymed verse unless its Yeats or somebody. I think you should bring that ancient tradition back. With odes to the blessed trees. Thanx for sharing. An enjoyable one.

P.S. is that a wolf in your photo he/shes very beautiful

John

Thank you for your nice words:))) I try different styles. Rhyming, for me, can be difficult, although I use it a lot. I don't want it to sound first grade:) I'm trying!! Thank you so much:)

Yes, "Grizzy B" AKA "Grizz" or "The Grizza" was a wolf dog. Sadly, we lost him March 15, 2009, due to cancer. I will never get over losing him...Hoping and praying to see him again, when I reach the other side. He was my heart...We still have "Sam" and he misses Grizz, also:(

Kind Regards,

wolfy

I forgot my old signature so this one will have to do for a while!

author comment

Bee, I really liked the idea of "rent."

Thank you for your time and critique:)

Kind Regards,

wolfy

I forgot my old signature so this one will have to do for a while!

author comment

Dear Wolfcat,

I had trouble with this poem.

first off, was the 'silent wintry cries'...which feels like a contradiction.

Then I tried to imagine the 'faded leaves' that had been reduced to dust. I was fine with that, it was the leaf dust breaking underfoot. Dust wouldn't really makes any noise or be felt underfoot. The snow would crunch, but the poem reads that it is the dust making the crunch. I am not trying to be difficult...but because of those lines, I lost interest in the poem.

The trees "stretch their fingers to the sky" in the first stanza, but then they are dormant forms in the final stanza...which doesn't compute to me, unless they have become dormant as the weather turns into Winter before they had their final stretch.

I, also, long for spring to come
And show its warm, bright face - bright face feels a little lame and forced.

I think all the words are there, they just need some logic included to make it flow effortlessly.

kind regards,

HS

--------------
Workshops are now open:
http://new.neopoet.com/workshop/find
--------------
With all that I am and all that I could be, I walk this earth, yet nobody sees me.

ever heard over poetic license? I love this piece.

cheers,
Jess
A new workshop on the most important element of poetry-
'Rhythm and Meter in Poetry'
https://www.neopoet.com/workshop/rhythm-and-meter-poetry

Jess,

I have heard of it...and am glad you 'loved' this poem...I just called it as I saw it.

HS

--------------
Workshops are now open:
http://new.neopoet.com/workshop/find
--------------
With all that I am and all that I could be, I walk this earth, yet nobody sees me.

I do not have time to answer everyone, today, as we have to DJ a party and this weekend is crammed full:)) I did want to answer you here and say that is exactly what I thought, but I also do not want to act like I cannot take "constructive" criticism, so "THANKS" for saying it for me, and now it matters not what I say:) I do understand that Dan has the right to not like my poem:)))

Will definitely be back to read and answer all of this advice and kind words on my work:))) I truly do appreciate it, very much!

A little info. about this poem: Sometimes, in the winter, I get the blues. That is where this poem came from. It came from the melancholy kind of angst that is almost debilitating. I guess I should have worked on it a bit, but it actually came out in less than 15 minutes. I just left it where it was. I cannot wait to come back and change it a bit, when I have time to read all of the suggestions. I "really" liked some of them a lot:)

Kind Regards,

catherine ~ AKA, "wolfycat"

I forgot my old signature so this one will have to do for a while!

author comment

Dear wolfycat,

It wasn't that I disliked the poem at all, I was just trying to close my eyes and picture the scene from your words. It didn't work for me, but I don't dislike the poem. Maybe it was just me not seeing this one as I should.

Allow me to come back to it at a later date and give it another try...is that alright with you?

Please don't think of me as a grumpy old man...I was just being honest with you as i saw it.

Kind regards and apologies if I came across badly, it wasn't my intention.

HS

Jess,

think I might need a workshop for myself to tell me how to critique properly and allow poetic licence to reign free. You are already mentoring one person...you may get another...me!

cheers,

HS

--------------
Workshops are now open:
http://new.neopoet.com/workshop/find
--------------
With all that I am and all that I could be, I walk this earth, yet nobody sees me.

I really need to monitor my commitment here as I have several video and sculpture projects going on that need my time and energy.

But I do intend to write a forum on critique, I am hoping to persuade Kelsey to come back and help with it, she is brilliant.

cheers,
Jess
A new workshop on the most important element of poetry-
'Rhythm and Meter in Poetry'
https://www.neopoet.com/workshop/rhythm-and-meter-poetry

I wish you would write an article about critique!! "I" need to read it, as I am pretty much a beginner with offering advice on other's works. If something really hits me in the gut, then I'll consider it. Otherwise, just because I don't always comment does not mean I am not reading the poems in the stream. I do totally agree on one poem per day. I am also creating art, making jewelry, taking care of horses, working, etc. and my time is very limited. I want to be able to get them all in:)))

Kind Regards,

wolfy

I forgot my old signature so this one will have to do for a while!

author comment

no worries:) Thank you for the nice note. I understand that not everyone will like what we write. There is something for everyone. Another of my thoughts is that a poem, depending on the imagery, can mean so many different things to different people. I have a difficult time commenting and giving advice on other people's poems. Firstly, I do not really feel qualified. I am in the first stages of learning about "critique." One never knows what the writer is feeling, thinking, etc., when writing something. The poems that are easiest for me to relate to are the ones that touch my heart. I'll quit blabbing:)))

Kind Regards,

wolfycat

I forgot my old signature so this one will have to do for a while!

author comment

Thank you for reading, your time, and critique:)))

Kind Regards,

wolfy

I forgot my old signature so this one will have to do for a while!

author comment

Far be it from this beginner to be too critical of a published poem.I liked the feeling and rhyme on a topic I often visit myself. Thanks for sharing................scribbler

Thank you very much for reading and for your kind words:)))

Kind Regards,

wolfy

I forgot my old signature so this one will have to do for a while!

author comment

The undressed oaks of winter [brilliant first line]
Stretch their fingers to the sky,
Contemplating autumn's end,
And sharing silent wintry cries.

Brown leaves have faded to the ground
And back again to dust,
Breaking underneath my feet,
Veiled beneath the frosty crust.

They stand helpless in the bitter cold, [helpless? maybe not]
Some bent from ancient storms,
Keeping watch in winter's twilight,
These majestic, dormant forms. [ a bit cliched]

Like these oaks, I now abide
In a haunting, cold embrace.
I, also, long for spring to come
And show its warm, bright face.

I would love to see a stronger ending." We endure all', "nothing destroys us", "our uprushing roots will fuck you in spring". Just a few suggestions, teehee

cheers,
Jess
A new workshop on the most important element of poetry-
'Rhythm and Meter in Poetry'
https://www.neopoet.com/workshop/rhythm-and-meter-poetry

I appreciate the time you have taken to read and critique my work:)

As soon as the weekend is over, I am coming back, looking again at the suggestions, and will edit from there to see how a change will affect this poem:)

Kind Regards,

wolfy

I forgot my old signature so this one will have to do for a while!

author comment

I enjoyed this poem.
For both, the imagery and the format.
Loved the strict sense of meter you have introduced.
To my ear it works pretty well throughout, except for the last line of each verse.

With the greatest of respect may I suggest a possible alternative below for your consideration. (I have, for ease of understanding, used capitalised font on all the stressed syllables, to show how I read this:)

The UNdressed oaks of winter
Stretch their FINgers to the sky,
CONtemplating autumn's end,
A SILent wintry cry.

Brown LEAVES have faded to the ground
And BACK again to dust,
BREAKing underneath my feet,
BeNEATH the frosty crust.

They stand HELPless in the bitter cold,
Some BENT from ancient storms,
Keeping WATCH in winter's twilight, these
MaJEStic, dormant forms.

LIKE these oaks, I now abide
In a HAUNTing, cold embrace.
I, ALSO, long for spring to come
And ONCE more show its face.

Thanks for sharing this one,

Psyve

Thank you very much for considering how my work can be improved!! I really appreciate it:)

I am going to edit this poem after the weekend is over and re-post:)

Was thinking about the last line. What do you think of:

"With its life renewing grace"

Kind Regards,

wolfy

I forgot my old signature so this one will have to do for a while!

author comment

They stand helpless in the bitter cold,
Some bent from ancient storms,
Keeping watch in winter's twilight,
These majestic, dormant forms.

I really liked this stanza, but do also like the suggestion to change bent to rent. Congratulations on the publications! I very much enjoyed the rhyming sequence.

always, Cat

*
When someone reads your work
And responds, please be courteous
And reply in kind, thanks.

Thank you for taking the time to read my work and for your suggestions.

I think "rent" will win:) This is the second suggestion for that:)

Kind Regards,

wolfy

I forgot my old signature so this one will have to do for a while!

author comment

I truly appreciate the time everyone has taken to suggest ideas and to critique my poem:) I will definitely be back to answer evryone, individually:0 We have a very busy weekend, over here, working and working on the facilities!

Kind Regards,

wolfycat

I forgot my old signature so this one will have to do for a while!

author comment

I love this write a great deal, for autunm is my favorite time of year, I 've written many poems on the subject.
your is absolutly fantiatic.
Eddie C.

LIFE ISN'T ABOUT WAITING FOR THE STORM TO PASS
IT'S ABOUT LEARNING HOW TO DANCE IN THE RAIN.
VIVIAN GREENE

I am happy you like this poem and I do appreciate your encouraging words:)

Kind Regards,

wolfy

I forgot my old signature so this one will have to do for a while!

author comment

I so appreciate your time and encouragement! Thank you for commenting on the imagery because I am trying to work on that aspect of my poetry. Sometimes, my stuff is pretty simple:)

Kind Regards,

wolfy

I forgot my old signature so this one will have to do for a while!

author comment
(c) Neopoet.com. No copyright is claimed by Neopoet to original member content.